An opinion cum suggestions to improve collegium system for judicial appointments.

To,
The Honorable Chief Justice of India &
Constitutional Bench headed by Justice JS Khehar on NJAC - Collegium Case WP(C) 13/2015,
Supreme Court of India,
New Delhi.

Respected Sir,

Subject: An opinion cum suggestions to improve collegium system for judicial appointments.

Why we should oppose National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC)?

Democracy is all about distribution of powers, it is constituted as 3 pillars Legislature, Judiciary and Executive. Due to political party system Legislative powers are concentrated in the hands of few party heads. They became as unofficial dictators of democracy, because of this both Legislature and Executive branches are in slavery. Executive branch failed to sustain its independence, due to their nexus and dependency on legislature for their day to day activities. NJAC bill is an attempt to bring Judiciary under their umbrella.

We are thankful to the Supreme Court of India for its historic verdict against NJAC. This verdict rescued the Judiciary from falling into the hands of Legislatures (Politicians), and stood tall to protect its autonomous status. Lot of criticism prevailed all these days due to lack of transparency and accountability in the appointment of Judges through Collegium system. SC's Constitutional bench willingness to accept suggestion from everyone to fix the Collegium, is a great and correct thing to do. It's my pleasure to give some below suggestions to help fix the Democratic system for good. Not only just the Collegium but entire Judiciary needs a makeover.

Autonomous Status:

As we all know Judiciary is an autonomous body, but still not independent enough to raise its finances and do the investigations. Our Legislature branch failed to give complete autonomy to the Judiciary. All State High courts should raise their funds by imposing a Judicial State Tax at state level and its state governments will be responsible to collect and transfer those taxes those respective state high courts. For Supreme Court, Central government should be responsible to collect and give Judicial Central Tax. CAG should audit the judicial expenditure. CAG, CBI and Election commission also deserve an autonomous status. CBI should have a separate wing to carry out investigations on behalf of Supreme Court, and should only report directly to the SC, but not to anyone else.

Minimum Qualification for Judges and PP's:

Minimum qualification to become Judge or Public Prosecutor (PP) should be a Masters in Law (ML) degree and minimum 5 years of law practice, and must be recruited only through a public service commission in lower courts.

Process to select High Court Judges:

To become High Court Judge, such person should have worked as Judge in lower court for at least 15 years. Interested candidates should apply to the State High Court registrar with their bio data along with 10 of their exemplary judgments, to prove their eligibility on or before 15th of Jan every year. Registry should add the statistics year wise how many cases were heard by them and how many cases were resolved. Chief Justice of that state will nominate 1/3rd of state judges as State Judges Collegium of that state and they will select and prepare the list of judges equivalent to the number of judges to that corresponding state by 15th of February every year. State Judges Collegium have a right to seek state intelligence report about the candidates to make an assessment.

SC should find out how many number of Judge's positions that are going to available by the end of June of for each current year (consider this figure as “X”) and the assessment for the same should be ready by the end of Feb of that year. Every High Court will have coefficient, which is derived from number of Judges in that High Court divided by total number of Judges in all High Courts. So total 2X plus few number of candidates should be selected for review from each high court. Coefficient of that high court multiplied by 2X should be rounded to the next highest number or at least one of the candidates should be selected from the top of each high court list for review by 15th March. This probable list will be sent to each high court Chief Justice for review, they should pick 1.5X (should be rounded to the next highest number) number of candidates from that list and should be sent to the Registrar of the Supreme Court of India. The SC registry should consolidate the list and publish it on 30th March. Candidates can withdraw their candidature by 5th April if they choose. On 6th April SC registry should order the CBI to enquire on the list of candidates. CBI should submit its report by 30th April.

Chief Justice of India should select the members of SC State Judges Collegium with 1/3rd of the SC judges and remaining 2/3rd of the SC judges as members of SC Judges Collegium by 5th April. The State Judges Collegium should sit in the 1st week of summer vacation and should select 1.2X candidates. Out of this list CJI should select the X number of judges and that list should be sent to the President of India for final approval. In case the President of India want to reject any candidate, The President should seek the CJI's inputs and then only the President should reject the candidate with an appropriate reason. The selected Judges should join in 1st week of July.

Process to select Supreme Court Judges:

In order to become as Supreme Court Judge, candidate should be a high court judge for 15 years, Chief Justice of high court should not be eligible to apply. Interested candidates should apply to the State registrar with their bio data along with 10 of their exemplary judgments as high court judge, to prove their eligibility on or before 15th of Jan each year. Registry should add the statistics by the end of February. The statistics should be based on how many cases were heard by them and how many cases were resolved with average number of days the case was heard year wise. Chief Justice of that state will short list the candidates and bring it down to no more than 1/3th of that state high court number of judges. And sends that list to SC Registrar by end of March. Chief Justice of that state have a right to seek state intelligence report about the candidates to make an assessment.

SC should find out how many number of SC Judge's positions which are going to available by the end of June of each current year (consider this figure as “Y”)and this assessment should be ready by the end of March that year. Every High Court should have coefficient, which is derived from Number of Judges in that High Court divided by total number of Judges in all High Courts.

Total 3Y plus few number of candidates should be selected by SC Registry for review, from each high court coefficient of that high court multiplied by the 3Y rounded to the next highest number or at least one of candidate should be selected from the top of each high courts list for review. The SC registry should consolidate the list and publish it by 15th April, Candidates can with draw their candidature by 20th April if they choose. On 21st April SC registry should order the CBI enquiry on the list of candidates. CBI should submit its report by 30th April. The consolidated list should be sent to SC Judges Collegium for its review. It will bring down the number to 1.5Y. Out of this list Chief Justice of India should select the Y number of high court judges and that list should be sent to the President of India for final approval. In case the President of India want to reject any candidate, The President should seek the CJI's inputs and then only the President should reject the candidate with an appropriate reason. The selected Judges should join SC in 1st week of July.

Other Selections:

Chief Justice of India and Chief Justice of High Court should be nominated according to their seniority, which is same as per current nominating system. All other Judicial appointees of state and central government representatives such as Attorney General, Government Pleaders / Prosecutors and PP's should be appointed through the respective State Judges Collegium or by SC Judges Collegium. All these appointees aren't eligible to become SC Judges.

Judge's Wages & Transfers:

High Court Judges should be transferred in between the high court's after finishing 5 years of service, Judges with 50 plus years of age should be exempted from transfers. SC Registry should prepare the list of judges to be transferred every year and submit it to SC Judges Collegium to take transfers. National Pay Commission appointed by the government of India should fix the pay structure and perks for judiciary, which will be constituted every 5 years by the Parliament.

Example:

Required number of High Court Judges (X) 45
Probable list of candidates 2X plus 105 selected from 604
Each high court Chief Justice will selects (1.5X) 68 out of 105
SC State Judges Collegium selects (1.2X) 54 out of 68
Chief Justice of India selects 45 out of 54

Required number of Supreme Court Judges (Y) 6
Probable list of candidates 3Y plus 32 selected from 201
SC Judges Collegium selects (1.5Y) 9 out of 32
Chief Justice of India selects 6 out of 9

Vande mataram

Thanking You
Vishnu Alluri

What do we need for AP? Special Status? Or Special Package?

As a matter of fact, we need both.

Some people are appealing that they are the only one who were talking about the special status and special package for AP. Some of our news channels prerogatives that no one had asked central government about what we need for AP. Some news channels were questioning about what does it mean by equality in Justice (sama nyayam) in bifurcating the state of Andhra Pradesh. But the fact is, I was the first person to start the dialogue about the best possibility and moreover most needed Special Status plus package to AP on the 3rd of Nov 2013 and the same has been sent the specifics with in the best promising knowledge of mine to GOM (Group Of Ministers appointed by the Central Government to rift the state of AP), to the news media and all our Andhra MP's. I strongly feel that, If it would have been published in the media, or if it would have been into the hands of Samaikyandhra activists at that time it could have had its implication and substantial role to stop the division. I am assertive that we could have been with healthier infrastructure with best package along with special status. Whoever is orating about special status or package for the state of Andhra Pradesh, for me they are conferring only about bits and pieces from my proposed demand that I have sent by emails to GOM, Press and Andhra MP's on the 3rd Nov 2013, as well as to Mr. Kiran Kumar Reddy and to Mr. Rahul Gandhi on 13th Nov 2013, to Mr. Jaiprakash Narayana (Loakstta) on 19th Nov 2013, to Mr. Narendra Modi and Mr. Rajnath Sing on 7th Feb 2014 and to Mr. Sivarama krishanan Committee on 23rd Apr 2014.

Please click here to read my APStatePackageV1.2 and to see the Proof.

Habitually, none of them have responded nor accredited my email suggestions. For sure, as I sturdily consider that some of them are expending my suggestions as if their own and attaining the credit of it. Though I am not supposing any glory out of it, I honestly appreciate if someone could certainly lead forward towards the enactment. I wish, at least everyone could know what we and the state of Andhra Pradesh are in need of, to survive. As I see, my ideas as proposed, will harvest respectable grades only if they are executed in total, otherwise there will be no use. Indian government has unconstitutionally divided our State, murdered the democracy of the Parliament and had desecrated the human rights. I have trailed two cases (PILs) in Supreme Court of India, Writ Petition (C) 207/2014 and 456/2014 were still in pending because of the bureaucracy in Supreme Court registry.

Despite of all our energies, we all have botched to get what we disparately need at the time of AP State bifurcation. But, at least now, we should seam our hands to get the most desired for the endurance of our AP State. With no other thought, both Congress and BJP along with the President of India, have embittered our Seemaandhra people for their simple selfish Political Calculations of AP State representation that will change in the Parliament from 42 MP’s to 25 MP’s in the State of AP and the new state Telangana representation with 17 MP’s.

Actually, in order to grant Special Status to any State, such bill must pass in both houses of the parliament with 2/3rd majority and it must be consented by 50 percent of the state assemblies, which is impossible. Though there is no urgency to get the bifurcation done within days, they have fore gone the procedure simply by saying that there is no enough time to send it to all State Assemblies. Even if they would have done it, definitely more than 50 percent of states would have opposed the Special Status to AP.

As per our Indian Constitution Article 368 (d) any change in the representation of States in Parliament, such bill must pass in both houses of the parliament with 2/3rd majority and it must be ratified by 50 percent of the state assemblies. And then, upon the approval of 50 percent of the state assemblies as a must, and only then, President of India can sign such a bill. But, AP State reorganization Bill 2014, has changed the role of representation of the states in Parliament by keeping everything aside, the President of India had signed the AP State reorganization Bill 2014, without sending it to all state assemblies. So, the act of the Central Government had eventually become unconstitutional. Union Govt. had stolen away the voting rights of the 28 States, which amounts to the violation of human rights.

Instead of Special Status cabinet granted Special Category Status for 5 years on 2nd Mar 2014, where, during the parliament discussions, the ruling Congress Party with the support of the opposition Party then, the BJP, had agreed to give Special Category Status for 10 years to the state of AP. Special Status is a guaranteed right under the Constitution, where, Special Category Status depends on the mercy of Central government.

As a special-category state AP can get significant excise duty and Income tax exemption to the industries which are moving to AP or to the new industries that are going to be setup in AP. We will get 90% as grant and 10% as loan instead of 70:30.

1. Give 50% income tax exemptions to the Industrialists who are moving their headquarters from Telangana state to AP State for 10 years. (Conditions: Industries which are paying more than 25 lacks. as income tax every year) The moved head quarter must stay in AP for at least for 20 Years.
2. Give import tax exemptions on medical equipment’s to all AP Corporate and Government hospitals for 10 years.
3. Give import tax exemptions for the machinery or equipment to all AP companies for 10 years.

For AP just Special Category Status isn't enough to survive, we also need to have a comprehensive Special package and it must be added to the constitution.

1. Since AP has a longest costal corridor, it is prone to cyclones. Our major income comes from formers. So, Central Govt. has to grant 1 lack crores as insurance fund for Crop guarantee program for farmers.
2. According to CAG AP State has 15,000 crore deficit budget, due to salaries hike we had another 5,000 crore deficit. So, Central government should be paying an amount of 25,000 crore every year to cover up the budget deficit for the next 25 years.
3. Grant 20,000 crores as grant for Capital Construction.
4. Complete the Polavaram project within 5 Years with Central government funds.
5. Construct Steel plant in Kadapa with SAIL.
6. There is a big disparity shown in AP division. UPA had distributed loans as per pro-rata based on the population to the ratio of 58:42 between AP and Telangana. As the known fact to everyone, most of the loans were brought to develop the Hyderabad. So it would be decently fair enough if the loans were distributed on the basis, for which and where they were spent. If not, 40:40:20 ratio, where 40% each to AP and Telangana and Center bearing 20%.
7. Need a special railway zone (South East Costal Railways) : Since all the railway revenue generated in AP is going to either Orissa (Bhubaneswar) or Telangana (Secunderabad) States, Build the zone headquarters with all the necessary facilities as a zone is very much needed in AP.
8. Roads: Build the APSRTC headquarters in Dornala of Prakasam district, Bus building unit in Uravakonda of Ananthapur district.
   • Expand NH 18 Kurnool – Nandyal – Kadapa – Chittor (369 KM) as 6 lane highway.
   • Expand NH 205 Anantapur - Kadiri - Madanapalle - Vayalpadu - Pileru - Tirupati - Renigunta - Puttur - Nagari (360 KM) as 6 lane highway.
   • Expand NH 63 Guntakal – Gooty (62 KM) as 6 lane highway and also extend it from Gooty – Mydakur – Badvel – Atmakur – Nellore by declaring AP State Highway 57 as NH 63.
   • Build a new 4 lines NH between Anantpur – Mydakur (or Kadapa).
   • Declare the AP State Highway 53 Nandyal – Giddallur AP State Highways 56 & 65 junction as 4 lines National Highway.
   • Declare the AP State Highways 56 & 65 Mydakur –– Cumbum – up to current AP State Highway 50 junction as 6 lines National Highway.
   • Declare the AP State Highway 50 Kurnool – Srisailam – Dornal – up to existing AP State Highway junction as 4 lines National Highway. From 65 junction – Vinukonda – Narasaraopet – Guntur – Vijayawada as 6 lines National Highway.
   • Declare the existing Narasaraopet – Sattenapalle road and extend it to Ibrahimpatnam as 6 lines National Highway.
   • NH 221 Ibrahimpatnam - Mylavaram - Cheemalapadu - Tiruvuru - Penuballi - Kothagudem - Paloncha - Bhadrachalam - Nellipaka - Chinturu - Konta up to Chhattisgarh border (155 KM) as 6 lane highway with divider.
   • Declare the AP State Highway 42 Suryapeta – khammam – Sattupally – Jangareddygudem – Polavaram and connect further to AP State Highway 38 – Bhupathipalem - Addateegala – Golugonda – Narsipatnam – Pendurthi – Vemulavalasa as 6 lines National Highway.
   • Build a new National highway Chodavaram – Ramabhadrapuram – Bhemasinghi – Vijayanagram as 6 lanes National Highway with divider.
9. Health care Infrastructure
   • Anantapur Institute of Medical Sciences with 1,000 bed inpatient hospital.
   • Visakha Institute of Medical Sciences with 1,000 bed inpatient hospital.
   • Guntur Institute of Medical Sciences with 1,000 bed inpatient hospital.
   • 1, 000 cores to rest of the district to improve hospitals.
10. Medical Collages
    • NTR Medical College (Course: MBBS) in Krishna district.
    • Sri Krishna Devaraya Medical College in Anantapur district.
    • Potti Sriramulu Medical College (Course: MBBS) in Nellore district.
    • AP College of Medical Sciences (Course: MBBS) in Srikakulam district.
11. There are12 Universities existing in Hyderabad. So establish the following in AP:
    • Indian School of Business in Krishna district.
    • Indian Institute of Technology in Anantapur district.
    • Birla Institute of Technology and Science, Pilani in Srikakulam district.
    • International Institute of Information Technology in Chittor district.
    • Jawaharlal Nehru Technological University in Anantapur district.
    • NALSAR University of Law in Guntur district.
    • Acharya N. G. Ranga Agricultural University in West godawari district.
    • Andhra Pradesh Open University in Kadapa district.
    • Potti Sreeramulu Telugu University in Nellore district.
    • English and Foreign Languages University in Vizianagaram district.
    • Institute of Chartered Financial Analysts of India (ICFAI) in Kurnool district.
12. There 7 Laboratories existing in Hyderabad. So establish the following in AP.
    • Andhra Pradesh Forensic Science Laboratory in Guntakal.
    • Aurora's Scientific, Technological and Research Academy – ASTRA in Guntur district.
    • Move Center for Indian Ocean Studies to Machilipatnam.
    • Central Forensic Sciences Laboratory in Palasa.
    • Defense electronics & research Laboratory in Srikakulam.
    • Defense Metallurgical Research Laboratory in Rayachoti.
    • Defense Research & Development Laboratory in Anakapalle.
13. Centers & Institutes: Distribute all the following for each district and make sure that they are not building in district headquarters. All these are existing in Hyderabad.
    • Atomic Minerals Directorate for Exploration and Research
    • Administrative Staff College of India
    • Bharat Dynamics Limited
    • Centre for Cellular and Molecular Biology
    • Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics
    • Centre for Economic and Social Studies
    • Central Power Research Institute
    • Central Institute of Tool Design
    • Central Research Institute for Dryland Agriculture
    • Central Institute for Medicinal and Aromatic Plants
    • Directorate of Rice Research
    • DRDO
    • English and Foreign Languages University (EFLU) (earlier CIEFL)
    • Hyderabad Eye Research Foundation
    • Indian Council of Agricultural Research
    • International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics
    • International School of Engineering
    • Institute for Development & Research in Banking Technology (IDRBT)
    • Institute of Public Enterprise
    • Indian Institute of Chemical Technology
    • Indian Immunological Limited
    • Institute of Lifesciences
    • Institute of Genetics and Hospital for Genetic Diseases
    • Indian Statistical Institute
    • Indian Institute of Planning and Management
    • Institute of Genetics and Hospital for Genetic Diseases
    • Laboratory of the Conservation of Endangered Species (LaCONES)
    • Media Mindz Institute for Films, Media & Animation (VytlaVasu Editing Institute)
    • Human Resource Development Institute of Andhra Pradesh
    • National Academy of Agricultural Research Management
    • National Geophysical Research Institute
    • National Institute of Nutrition
    • Indian National Centre for Ocean Information Systems
    • Engineering Staff College of India
    • National Institute of Fashion Technology
    • JNTU National Academy of Construction
    • National Geophysical Research Institute
    • Center of Plant Molecular Biology
    • National Remote Sensing Agency, India's Satellite Monitoring Station
    • National Centre for Compositional Characterization of Materials
    • National Institute of Plant Health Management
    • Tata Institute of Social Sciences(TISS)
    • Aero Space Park
14. Central govt. should create a River Authority of India (RAI) and nationalize all the rivers, lakes and dams in India, should make all the state Chief ministers as board members and Prime Minister as Managing Director , they will have voting rights based on the weighted average of their responding state population and they amount of water flows through that state. The current tribunals are allocating the water based on past availability. RAI should allocate water on monthly basis based on the availability of the water for that month. States which are drawing the water from Dam, should pay their share for maintenance costs for Dams. We need to interlink the rivers for better utilization of water.
15. Make sure that the any natural resources which are available in the state must be used within the state. After fulfilling the 85% of its need then only it can be allocated to export out of the state.
16. For the people who want to move back to AP state from Telangana state, the govt. should buy their properties as per the current registration value, or possibly at the market value, plus pay another 2 lacks as compensation. Keep this offer open only for 3 years.

Hope that you had by now, understood my concerns and the way I have tried to justify the all corners of the state to give equilateral development to the entire state. I wish you could take this forward either by yourself or by sharing with someone who could understand and stand to it, till we get what we are supposed to have as a right for all the sacrifices and losses incurred during this selfish and foolish political act of this state bifurcation.

Vande mataram

Thanking You
Vishnu Alluri

SECTION 8

People across the Telugu community have several questions about Section 8 of AP State Reorganization Act 2014; Media is irresponsibly airing the nonsense, but what is the real Truth? Let's find out.

Section 8

          (1) On and from the appointed day, for the purposes of administration of the Common Capital Area, the Governor shall have special responsibility for the security of life, liberty and property of all those who reside in such area.

          (2) In particular, the responsibility of the Governor shall extend to matters such as law and order, internal security and security of vital installations, and management and allocation of Government buildings in the common capital area.

          (3) In discharge of the functions, the Governor shall, after consulting the Council of Ministers of the State of Telangana, exercise his individual judgment as to the action to be taken:

          Provided that if any question arises whether any matter is or is not a matter as respects which the Governor is under this sub-section required to act in the exercise of his individual judgment, the decision of the Governor in his discretion shall be final, and the validity of anything done by the Governor shall not be called in question on the ground that he ought or ought not to have acted in the exercise of his individual judgment.

          (4) The Governor shall be assisted by two advisors to be appointed by the Central Government.

If we read above text of section 8, it is very clear that it should be implemented from "on and from the appointed day" i.e., 2nd June 2014 and Governor shall have special powers to hold Law and Order of joint capital city Hyderabad (Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation Area).

Why isn't it implemented till date then? Telangana region leaders opposed this section at the time of drafting AP State Reorganization Act 2014, however, they didn’t object it vehemently with a fear that if they do so, it might impact passage of the bill and they won't get Telangana state; to this extent they didn’t raise any objections at that time. Also, the new BJP government wished to avoid any nuisance as soon as they sworn in, by implementing the reorganization bill as-is (especially Section 8). It is also partly delayed because of TDP party, as they believed they are strong in both the states. While dividing the state, Congress party was under the impression that they can come to power, if not in both the Telugu Speaking States at least in Telangana, and then control AP through the Governor; they didn't consider alternative scenario what if rival parties came into power. Just like TRS, had any Andhra focused party had come to power on the other side, then the rivalry between the states would have been so hot that the chances of implementing Section 8 from 2nd June 2014 would have been very high.

Currently situation in Hyderabad is very peaceful, and law and order is under control; then why is the Central govt. considering to implement Section 8 now? As we all know, implementation of this section has already delayed for a year now, and as per the act it has to be implemented sooner or later. Also, both the state CM's are fighting against each other, and we don't know when the law and order can turn into chaos. This would be the right occasion to implement it.

If Telangana leaders say that they don't obey the Section 8, then AP leaders will object some other section, then what would be the situation? Both leaders have to obey the Act otherwise we will be back to square one.

Telangana leaders are saying that TDP brought this Section 8 issue in order to cover up Note for Vote case. Though this can be true to an extent, having the law and order under Governor’s control, doesn’t mean the Note for Vote case will cease to exist. Still the case would have to take its own course per the court rules.

Telangana leaders are claiming that Section 8 can only be implemented in a situation when the law and order is not in control. That's not true as no such condition or text exists in Section 8 of the Reorganization Bill. If what Telangana leaders claim is true, and they still wish to be law abiding, then as per Article 3 of the Indian constitution, President can't use Article 3 to divide a state and send a bill to any state; he can a send bill only to alter boundaries in case of dispute between states. This can be drawn from Article 3's 5th amendment, since the text exists in this, to get best interpretation out of it. This point is pending with Supreme Court of India in WP (C) 207 of 2014. As per this argument, AP division is unconstitutional. Will Telangana leaders abide by this law then?

Telangana leaders are claiming that the Governor can act only as per the wish of the Telangana Govt. This also absolutely wrong, since Section 8(3) categorically stated that the "decision of the Governor in his discretion shall be final and the validity of anything done by the Governor shall not be called in question".

Telangana leaders are making one more claim that the implementation of Section 8 is a Presidential rule. It's another absolute lie. In President Rule, Legislature's assembly will be in suspended animation mode, and CM and the cabinet will lose its powers. If Section 8 is implemented, assembly still runs normally and the cabinet also runs normally. Only law and order within the GHMC area will be under Governor's control and cabinet going to do all administrative tasks and development.

According to reports in several news channels, Telangana CM KCR called CMs from all other states and asking their support since the Central (BJP) Govt. is encroaching in to the state's rights. Telangana state itself was formed with Central (UPA / Congress) Govt. encroachment. Previous state divisions in India happened only after corresponding state assembly approved the bill. But in AP case it got separated, even after State assembly rejected the division bill in writing and with voice vote. As per Article 1, Indian states are sovereign and the states have the right for self-existence. This point is also pending with Supreme Court of India in WP (C) 207 of 2014.

Corruption doesn’t necessarily occur in the form of cash and kind; it can occur in any form. In the case of AP State division, UPA govt. abused political power, misused the Article 3 and it undermined the rule of law to manipulate human weakness, to get benefit out of it in the form of votes and to come back in to the power, this is nothing but corruption at higher level.

Justice has been denied and delayed for Andhra Pradesh State, Members (All States) of Indian Union and fellow citizens of India, we all are victims of power abuse and our Human rights are violated as per Human Rights Council's resolution A/HRC/RES/7/11. Human Rights are derived from the Constitution. Constitutional violations are more dangerous than any other type of violations.

As of date, 35 plus cases are pending with Supreme Court of India since Dec 2013, in relation to the AP State Division issue. I hope that the section 8 issue flare up a bit more, so it will enable the Supreme Court to take up the AP State division cases seriously.

Vande mataram

Thanking You
Vishnu Alluri

Suggestions for better Metro Plan for Visakhapatnam.

I visited New York City first time in 1999, it was an amazing experience, I wondered how it is possible to build such a city. Later on I watched PBS Documentary on TV (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lUmI6mUzSH8) and came to know about the American Builder Robert Moses, the Architect of New York City. He is the greatest creator and builder of Public Works. He earned billions of dollars for the city, He wasn’t interested in personal wealth, only interested in the public benefit. I got inspired by him, from that day onwards I was looking for the opportunity to do the same.

Recently AP State government planned to build Visakhapatnam Metro project, I am so disappointed that the proposed plan is useless and waste of money and it won’t yield any benefit to the people or to the government.


DMRC proposed 3 Metro corridors, its total length is 34 KM.

Corridor1: from Madhurawada to NAD Junction along NH5.

Corridor2: Thatichetlapalem to Old post office via railwany new colony, railway station, alliupuram, Ambedkar Statue, Jagadamba Junction, Purna market and Reading Room.

Corridor3: Gurudwara NH5 Junction to Park hotel via Seethampeta, RTC Complex, Siripuram and AU out gate.

I was born in King George Hospital (KGH) Visakhapatnam, I know the traffic patterns of this city very well. I want to share one of my plans for better Visakha, it’s going to help the public and government, I would love to help much more. The main city of Visakhapatnam is surrounded by hills and sea, didn’t have enough space to grow. Gajuwaka developed in much faster way and it is completely in disconnect with main city. Steel Plant, NTPC, Pharma City and Gangavarm Port stretched the Gajuwaka further south. Arilova and Madhurawada’s growth expanded Visakhapatnam towards North East. And also it stretched from Gopalpatnam to Pendurthi toward North West.

Most of the commuters from Madurawada, Arilova and MVP Colony travel towards Old post office, RTC Complex and Railway Station, remaining go to Gujuwaka and further, they don’t end their journey at NAD Junction. Half of the commuters from Pendurthi, Vepagunta and Gopalapatnam travel to RTC complex, Railway Station and Jagadamba Junction, remaining travel towards Gajuwaka and beyond. Pilgrims from Railway station, RTC Complex and Gajuwaka travel to Simhachalam. Another busier route is from Railway station to Scindia Junction and from Scindia to Gajuwaka because of Naval Dockyard, Hindustan Shipyard and HPCL.

I recently visited New Delhi 3 times to attend AP State Bifurcation cases in Supreme Court of India, I used the metro all the time, it is convenient but I observed buses also running in parallel to metro trains. It means we are sharing the commuters between buses and metro trains, this doesn’t help the environment much. When we observe overseas buses they carry the commuters from the remote places to metro train stations. It forces people to use metro trains. And it reduces the traffic and helps the environment. After considering all the above reasons I would like to suggest the following plans for better and grater Visakha.

Plan A


Total length of 2 Metro corridors is around 52 KM.

Corridor1 (30KM) Madhurawada to Kurmanna Palem (Vizag Steel Plant plaza road) via Arilova, Kailashigiri, Maddilapalem, Rama takies, RTC Complex, Jagadamba Junction, Purna market, Reading Room, Old Post office, Dolphin Hill, Scindia junction, Malkapuram and Chaitanya Nagar (Gajuwaka).

Corridor2 (22KM) Pendurthi to Vuda Beach via Vepagunta, Gopalapatnam, Tatichetlapalem, Akkayapalem, Gurudwara, Maddilapalem, Through AU North Campus and Chinna waltair.

With this proposal we can reduce 70% of the City buses. The high rise metro track over the channel above 100 meters connecting old post office station and Dolphin Hill will attract the Tourists. We can develop the Dolphin hill similar to Kailashgiri and promote Light house,weather station, Durga temple and beach. Through Corridor1 visitors can travel between Kailashgiri and Dolphin Hill. We can promote the Religious tolerance as a symbolic junction of Church on Ross hill, Masjid on one hill and Hindu Venkateswara temple on the other hill.

Plan B

Visakhapatnam Railway station is blocking most of the prime area in the center of the city. Anakapalli – Visakha and Viskha – Pendurthi railway line forms Y junction all the trains coming from Anakapalli and Pendurthi passing through a clogged passage and causing around extra 20 KM travel and wasting more than one hour of time of each passenger. We can streamline this by shifting Visakha Railway station and building it between Kakaninagar and Gopalapatnam Rural station. This will bring Visakhapatnam Railway station and Airports across the road. Indian Railways can gain by selling the prime area of existing railway station lands and can move them away from the city.

Total length of 4 Metro corridors is around 70-75 KM


Corridor1 BLUE Line (30KM) Madhurawada to Kurmanna Palem (Vizag Steel Plant plaza road) via Arilova, Kailashgiri, Maddilapalem, Rama talkies, RTC Complex, Jagadamba Junction, Purna market, Reading Room, Old Post office, Dolphin Hill, Scindia junction, Malkapuram, Chaitanya Nagar (Gajuwaka)

Corridor2 GREEN Line (20KM) Pendurthi to Peda Gantyada via Vepagunta, Gopalapatnam, Airport, New Railway Station, AkkireddyPalem, Jyothinagar, New Gajuwaka and Nehrunagar.

Corridor3 RED Line (12KM) New Railway Station to Vuda Beach via Airport, NAD, Marripalem, kancharapalem, Tatichetlapalem, Akkayapalem, Lalithanagar, Maddilapalem, Through AU North Campus and Chinna waltair.

Corridor4 YELLOW Line (8KM) New Railway Station to Simhachalam via Airport, Gopalapatnam, and Prahaladapuram.

With this Plan B we can reduce 85% of the City buses and it will give a new dimension to Visakhapatnam development, it will expand in West and North West directions.

Thanking You
Vishnu Alluri

We need a Citizen’s Security System.

Yesterday’s terror threat reminded me the article I wrote “Citizen Security System” on 6th Dec 2008 after 26/11 Mumbai attacks. I would like to share it as follows…

---

We all are bleeding from our hearts and deeply wounded, we don’t have words, what we have is only the anger to show.

Pakistani Politicians and Army survival depends on anti-Indian sentiment and by propagating it. No one has any doubt to say Pakistan is a terrorist country. In recent time’s pak politician’s talks about war on terror at front, in the back they are encouraging and sponsoring terror. There is no radical Islam before 1980’s it has been created by Pakistanis with American funds, in order to gather men to fight against soviets in Afghanistan. Pakistan diverted most of these funds to fight against India in the name of Kashmir issue, not for the Kashmiri’s. After Soviets withdrawal all jihads don’t have a target to hate. Pakistani terrorists turned against India and others are against western countries especially US and UK in the name of Palestine and rest are wanted to create bigger Islamic state. First two kinds can be eliminated but not the third kind, the world has to face it forever.

It look like Pakistani President Mr. Zardari knows about this attack, they want war with India to divert US from its war on terror. His recent statement that “Pakistan won’t detonate nuclear weapon first on India” this comment came with surprise and without any context. He is hinting the India that it can fire few missiles after 26/11 attack.

With booming economy we are moving towards capitalism, in the process we are moving towards US and west, for terrorist’s its not easy to strike western countries at their will, but India is a soft target because of its corruption, leader’s inability and overcrowded population. For these reasons we will take major impact in the coming future.

With 9/11 attacks and because of some Bollywood movies it became as a fascination to become as terrorist in India. It is nothing but Sinicism and psychopath mentality. All the communal riots are politically motivated or definitely some anti-social elements are behind for their own benefit so far our politicians failed us to capture and punish the perpetrators and to prevent these events, Terrorists are using these incidents as their propaganda weapons.

Most of our Politicians are selfish and worthless they don’t do anything and they can’t do anything. Corruption is at unacceptable level, it became as integral part of our government and society. Anyone can buy birth certificates, ration cards, driving licenses and so on, and can start contesting in our ballets. In reality we can’t prevent attacks but the damage can be minimized.

We have right to express our anger and concerns. We never did it before when our democracy is on stake or over unemployment or skyrocketing prices. It’s welcoming and most desirable change that India needed. We must express our concerns publicly; the sad thing is that some are posting their comments over the web with duplicate names. Please do with your real names, don’t be afraid its freedom of speech, it’s our fundamental right.

We are watching some action only because elections are around the corner; it’s nothing, there are lot of more things has to be done. We must come out and demand what we want. We must start electing our leaders based on the merits not on the basis of his/her political party or cast or religion.

We badly need a Citizen’s Security System to protect our citizens from terrorist attacks and communal riots. This CSS will respond on their won without any chain of commands or without any interference from center or state govt. officials or politicians. Any police station can call directly for help or CSS field officers can call them.

CSS should have 5 Terror Response Zones (East, West, North, South and Central). Each zone consisting of 5,000 army soldiers and 5,000 army commandos trained for antiterrorism, guerilla, and urban, rural, biological and nuclear warfare and with 4 airplanes and 10 helicopters.

• In a zone there should be a First Response Team with 500 members, they should work in 4 shifts, with 100 members per shift, they should be ready for deployment within 5 to 10 minutes, and one plane should be ready to take off at any moment with full of armor and ammunition.
• After FRT’s departure the first Reinforcement Team (with 250 commandos) should be get ready for air lifting in 30 minutes and 2nd Reinforcement should be get ready for air lifting in an hour if necessary.
• Each operation should have a one command center in its zonal office it should work 24/7, each zone could be able to take up to 50 operations at the same time.
• Each commando should have complete protection (ready for Bio and Nuclear attacks) suites with latest weapons and night vision capability and should carry a web camera (can be recorded at zonal office with voice over secure connection) and communication systems. All operations should be conducted from their zonal command center. Commandos should be air dropped in a safe and close to hot spot.
• Each zone should have several field officers deployed all over the places; they should acquire the complete knowledge of the area, streets and places. In the event of attack or riots these field officers can call the zonal offices for help. These are responsible for looking out safe places for commando’s air drop locations and should guide them to the hot spot.
• In the event of attack TRZ’s should scan all the incoming and outgoing communications from land and mobile phones, faxes and computers.
• Zonal office location must be setup in a way that flight journey should take below 30 minutes to reach any extreme end. Each zone should establish a regional office in every metro city and sensitive places with 60 commandos they will also work in 4 shifts. Each RO get one helicopter, it should be able to carry 15 commandos and ammunition and should be used to chase the suspects and for Arial coverage.
• TRZ’s should inform the TV stations, Press, Air ports, Railway stations, Bus stations, sport complexes, movie theaters and public places automatically within 10 minutes of the incident.
• When an attack starts, 144 Section should be in effect around 1km radius. Local police should block the incoming traffic and evacuate the roads and guard the hospitals and help the victims to carry into hospitals. Announcing the warning and suggestions over the loud speakers.
• TV stations must announce the affected areas, helpline phone numbers and suggestions like stay in the home and don’t come on to the roads and so on.
• When attack took place air ports, railway and bus stations of the city must start recording its entry and exit points. They should be on high alert. Incoming trains and buses must be stopped at previous scheduled stop. Outgoing trains and buses must leave at scheduled time and must be stopped until thorough inspection in their next stations at least 50 or 100km away from the hot spot.
• Electricity should be shut off; cell phones should be blocked with jammers after 30 minutes of attack and must be restored as soon as the commandos operation is over or if it is secure to do so.
• Zonal offices will provide a 30 minute delayed live feed and information to press and TV reporters, without compromising the public safety and without affecting the ongoing investigation.
• After a month all recorded information without any sensor must be produced to loksatta kind of organizations, any wrong doing by the CSS must be prosecuted.
• Commando’s age must be in between 20 to 30 years, they must be transferred back to the army after 5 years of service in CSS and the vacancies must be filled with new members.
• Investigation Teams should reach the hot spot as soon as the operation ends.
• Commandos must sanitize the hot spot and thoroughly investigate for the clues, all the evidences must be handed over to the CSS headquarters and the hot spot must be handed over to the local police. Until then either politicians or officials are not allowed to visit the hot spot.
• CSS Headquarters should keep in touch with intelligent agencies; state and central government’s and exchange the information with them. Coordinate and govern the TRZ’s.

Vande mataram

Thanking You
Vishnu Alluri

How to solve interstate water disputes and purify our rivers including Ganga?‏

Erratic rainfall and a growing population have raised the demand for water and it sparking interstate spats. The tribunals are failing to solve water sharing disputes between the states and the cases are stagnating at the Supreme Court of India. Because of political parties vote bank politics they are using it as a weapon, it will flare up the enmity between peoples of different states, and ultimately it will threaten the integrity of India. Some state governments are building the Dam’s without permission’s which is leading to lawlessness in the country. By year 2030 the demand of water supply is going to be doubled, so it is the right time to act.

Central govt. should create a River Authority of India (RAI) and nationalize all the rivers, lakes and dams in India, should make all the state Chief ministers as board members and Prime Minister as Managing Director , they will have voting rights based on the weighted average of their responding state population and they amount of water flows through that state. The current tribunals are allocating the water based on past availability. RAI should allocate water on monthly basis based on the availability of the water for that month. States which are drawing the water from Dam, should pay their share for maintenance costs for Dams. We need to interlink the rivers for better utilization of water. We should add one more Fundamental Right to our constitution to get 10 liters of treated water per day for drinking and cooking, and government will be responsible to supply.

Guideline’s to formulate and allocate water for each state.

1. First it should allocate 200 Liters per person for basic daily consumption.
2. It should allocate water for Hydro Power stations to run 24 hours.
3. It should allocate water for Irrigation systems, first preference should be given to naturally flowing system then for lift irrigation systems one crop per year.
4. It should allocate water to Industries.
5. Excess water should be allocated for Irrigation systems, first preference should be given to naturally flowing system then for lift irrigation systems for second crop in that year.
6. For Drinking water and Hydro Power stations allocations should be based on top – down approach.
7. Irrigation and Industrial allocations should be based on down – top approach.

Currently 80% of the City’s untreated sewage is flowing into the rivers, lakes and ponds, as a result Nitrate levels are too high in ground water all around the India, not only this untreated industrial waste is flowing through the rivers and polluting all the water resources, it is creating the hazardous conditions to public health . As per Article 47 of Indian Constitution the duty of the State is to raise the level of nutrition and the standard of living and to improve public health, So far our rulers failed to improve or to protect the public health. Most urgently needed action is to clean all the Rivers. Our newly elected Prime Minister Mr. Narendra Modi took the first step to clean our Ganga River, I would like to contribute myself to this project and suggest the following new innovative processes to clean up our precious rivers round the clock.

Process 1: Construct 3 pipe lines on both sides along the rivers banks. One pipe for Drinking water, one pipe for Sewage water and one pipe for Industrial Liquid Waste. It will help us to block the sewage water and industrial liquid waste flowing into the rivers. RAI will be responsible to lay down these lines and establish Treatment Centers for every 100KM to treat sewage and industrial liquid waste and drinking water treatment. State governments will be responsible to facilitate and mandate the industries, cities and villages to connect the sewage and industrial waste to the main pipe (RAI laid) lines.

Process 2: Construct River Float Collector (RFC) at every 100 KM. It will collect all the floating objects like plastic bottles, covers, trees and dead bodies.

Process 3: Construct River Silt Collector (RSC) at possible locations and before dam reservoirs to clean up the silt (Sedimentation) round the clock from reverbed (underwater).

 

Take the preventive measures to reduce the sedimentation, such as planting trees and draft walls to stop the land sliding. And also use conventional dredgers in Dam reservoirs to remove sedimentation. Re-excavate the rivers to deepening and to remove the sedimentation and to strengthen the river banks.

This project needs lots of money and long term commitment. It is most desired and essential project to meet our future water supply demand. Supreme Court of India is keeping lots of pressure on government of India to clean Ganga river, but what about other rivers? Government of India told that it will take 18 years just to clean Ganga River, when it is going to start and finish the cleaning remaining rivers? Let’s step up and speak up for cleaning of all the rivers.

Vande mataram.

Thanking You
Vishnu Alluri

14th Planning Commission Report, A wake up call to AP people.

Indian Parliament passed Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Bill 2013 undemocratic way through voice vote against the will of Seemandhra people. It was a lousy bill, both the new states are struggling and quarreling for the resources. They divided a self-sustained AP State in two spineless dependent states. As per 14th Planning commission report Telangana state will be with 1,00,000 crores surplus and left over AP State will be with 22,000 crores deficit by 2019, what kind of justice is this? Congress and BJP promised in Parliament to fulfill the revenue deficit of AP State during the bifurcation, Now BJP paying only the 22,000 crores, but AP State has a deficit of 1,22,000 crores when it compared to Telangana state. If not they are supposed to distribute the surplus (1,00,000 – 22,000) 78,000 crores to both states 58% plus 22,000 crores to AP and 42% to Telangana, 58-42 is the basis formula for the division. 

Parliament promised Special category status to AP for 5 years, political parties’ poll promise was 10 years. But now the Special category status is in question. 

Polavaram project was declared as national project during the division, only 100 crores is allocated to it in 2015-16 budget. Total cost of project is 20,000 crores as per 2015 estimation. 

Another promise was a Special package / Incentives to 7 backward districts of AP State. Bundelkhand, MP and Orissa got this kind of package through Backward Region Grant Fund (BRGF) scheme, now the BJP discontinued this scheme and just paid 350 crores to AP in this regard. 

13th schedule of bifurcation Act promised the following educational institutions in AP IIM, IIT, IIIT, IISER, NIT, Central University, Petroleum University, Agricultural University and Tribal University. AP State will provide land and Central govt will allocate money. So far Center allocated 300 Crores, Just IIM and IIT alone costs 2,700 crores. 

AIMS and National Institute of Disaster Management NIDM also part of the act, new AIMS were allocated to Tamil Nadu, Punjab, Assam, and Jammu Kashmir states in 2015-16 budget, they ignored AP. 

The act directs to examine the establishment of new Railway zone for AP within 6 months and take expeditious decision. So far no decision was taken, We badly need a new South East Coast Railways (SECR) Zone with Guntakal, Guntur, Vijyawada and Visakhapatnam (Waltair) divisions. If not all our Guntakal, Guntur and Vijyawada divisions money goes to Telangana (SCR) and Viskhapatnam (Waltair) division money goes to Orissa (ECR). 

So far no steps are taken for Infrastructure promises Duggarajpatnam Port, Vizag – Chennai Industrial Corridor, Greenfield Oil Refinery and Petrochemical Complex, Expansion of Vizag, Vijyawada and Tirupathi airports with International Standards. There wasn’t any allocation for Capital development in 2015-16 budget. 

Congress misinterpreted and misused Article 3. As per Article 1, Indian States are Sovereign. President of India doesn’t have a right to divide a state without the consent of concerned State Assembly. 

Any bill which is going to change the Representation (number of MP’s) of States in Parliament as per Article 368 must be approved with 2/3rd majority in both houses of the Parliament and also it must be sent to all State Assemblies for their approval. At least 50% of the State Assemblies must approve it, and then only the President of India can sign such a bill. UPA didn’t send the bill to all State Assemblies and violated Article 368 and took away the voting rights of all 28 States, this is nothing but human rights violation. National Human Rights Commission declined to take up this case since the same matter is pending in Supreme Court. SC failed to take up this case through its suo-motu action and to protect the Constitution, on top of it, SC is delaying the petitions by saying that the matters are incomplete, since some of the respondents didn’t received petition copies in some AP State bifurcation petitions. 

Article 371d brought into the constitution with 2/3rd majority in both the houses of Parliament and with 50% of the State Assemblies approval in 1973 through 32nd amendment for equal opportunity in jobs and educational institutions in Capital City of Hyderabad. Now these Constitutional Rights are taken away from Andhra and Rayalaseema people through voice vote with simple majority. Does the Union of India have any right to take away the Constitutional rights of the people, which were promised 30 years ago? Could the Union of India dare to take away the Article 370, same way from the State of Jammu and Kashmir? 

Sooner or later the Supreme Court of India is going to declare the AP State Reorganization Act 2014 as unconstitutional and it must be reverted. 

At least with 14th Planning Commission Report AP people should come out of their illusions, So far Union of India didn’t paid even 5,000 crores to any newly formed states, don’t dream that the Center is going to help generously or fulfills its promises. It’s time to realize and should get ready to agitate for Justice and to protect their AP State and future. Get ready to work with hand in hand. 

Thanking You

Vishnu Alluri

SPECIAL NUCLEAR DEAL (123 Agreement)

I read article “Need of the hour is for ‘Make-in-India’ nuclear plants” in Deccan Chronical was written by Dr. Gopalakrishnan (agk37@hotmail.com) is a former chairman of India’s Atomic Energy Regulatory Board. It reminded me of my old article on this issue, it was written on 20th July 2008 and as usual I failed to get Indian press attention. Epilog to this article is Left parties withdrew their oxygen support to UPA-1 government and Mr. Manmohan Singh was seeking confidence motion on 22nd July 2008, and Congress party was offering 30 crores to support or abstention in the vote in order to survive confidence vote in parliament. 

As we all know Cash for Votes Scandal broke the headline on 22nd and Kishore Chandra Deo committee didn’t find any evidence. 2 MP’s from AP State Mr. Manda Jagannadham and Mr. D. K. Adikeshavulu Naidu of TDP voted to UPA-1, within 6 months Mr. Adikeshavulu Naidu became the TTD Chairman, isn’t it bribery? Aren’t they done this on public watch? We are ….. 

SPECIAL NUCLEAR DEAL 

It’s so cheap to buy MP’s it costs only around 25 to 30 crores, The whole Parliament costs just 8,250 crores (275 MP’s X 30 C). Any G 8 nation can easily spend much more than this in order to get whatever they want in India, Why not just American govt. go ahead and buy 275 MP’s to get India into NPT? Why with this “SPECIAL Nuclear Deal” agreement? Don’t you think they are smart? They are doing this through a deal, to favor for their “SPECIAL BUSINESSMEN” and achieving their goal to get India into NPT framework. The N deal is above 400, 000 crores capital investment in first 5 years to generate 20,000MW by year 2020, definitely someone will get at least 1% as commission, i.e. 4,000 cores. Easily they can buy 40 MP’s by offering 100 crores each, may be they are keeping that for coming elections. Are you getting ready to get some of it by demanding for your vote in 2009 elections? 

We are the biggest democratic nation in the world, we are well deserved and qualified enough to get permanent membership in UN, no other country is qualified if India isn’t qualified. US is not supporting us on this issue but why they are supporting us to get Uranium, despite of its worldwide opposition by doing a special agreement with us? 

So far we (India) didn’t sign the NPT treaty, because it favors the nuclear nations only. They will have excess pileup of weapons in their arsenal, they don’t want to disarm them, but they will block or demolish the other nation who try to acquire this technology, is it fair? In past U.S and USSR agreed to dissolve some of their stocks, but both countries dumped that agreement. Indian govt. has enormous pressure from long time to sign NPT; by signing this we can buy the Uranium from the NSG nations without restrictions but by not signing does India lost something? Is this is the reason, as now we are signing with US? In which form the 123 agreement different from NPT? 

US built its last nuclear power plant in 1975, they are not pursuing it because of its destructive nature and the difficulties to treat its waste. German’s are investing their money in solar energy, then why should we invest in nuclear? We don’t have enough Uranium mines we must depend on others forever. India has world’s second largest reserves of Thorium and efforts are on to develop Thorium based fast breeder reactors in India, why shouldn’t we invest that money on Thorium based fast breeder reactors or Solar? 

To build a nuclear reactor, it takes long span such as 9-10 years, per MW capital investment is 28 Crores plus Uranium and its transportation, waste treatment and high maintenance cost, Instead of that if we build Solar PV power plants, it can built in a year, per MWp without batteries 12 crores for 40 years, to get same output as nuclear we need 8MWp power plant with a capital investment of 96 crores plus minimum maintenance cost no additional costs because sunlight is free. We can start using it 9 years before the nuclear power plant is constructed. Without constructing new ones we should buy uranium for our existing reactors. 

Mr. Kalam’s stand on this issue as President of India is best to support Thorium reactors other than signing this deal. After his US visit as ex-President of India, he is in favor of this deal. Sonia Gandhi never commented on this deal until her last visit to US in 2007 Oct. After that she called the opponents of this deal as traitors. Amar Sing is flip flopping on this issue and now he is in favor of it after his arrival from US Doesn’t it look odd? Does our politicians are doing slavery? Or they are blackmailed? Or they took bribes?

Vande mataram

Thanking You
Vishnu Alluri